Christmas is a time full of joy, laughter, and festive moments. One of the easiest ways to bring people together during the holidays is by playing “Would You Rather?” It’s a simple game that sparks fun conversations, silly debates, and surprising choices. Kids, teens, and adults enjoy it because there are no right or wrong answers, just creativity and holiday fun.

Below, you’ll find more than 60 Christmas “Would You Rather” questions you can use at school, holiday parties, family gatherings, or cozy nights at home. These questions are playful, friendly, and perfect for all ages.

Before getting started, we would like to recommend to you our random topic generator tool, which allows you to generate unlimited types of questions.

Funny Would You Rather Questions

These questions add humor to your game and make everyone laugh.

1. Would you rather wear an itchy Christmas sweater or socks that play music all day?
2. Would you rather decorate 100 cookies or wrap 100 presents?
3. Would you rather have a snowman follow you everywhere or a reindeer follow you everywhere?
4. Would you rather have Santa’s laugh or the Grinch’s grin?
5. Would you rather only talk in Christmas song lyrics or only jingle when you walk?
6. Would you rather sleep on wrapping paper or sleep on a pile of candy canes?
7. Would you rather have Rudolph’s glowing nose or Frosty’s carrot nose?
8. Would you rather get stuck in a giant snow globe or a giant gingerbread house?
9. Would you rather your hair smell like peppermint forever or smell like pine trees forever?
10. Would you rather your voice sound like an elf or like Santa?

If you love these, you should also check out the Christmas trivia questions list too.

Kid-Friendly Would You Rather Questions

Perfect for younger players and family-friendly games.

11. Would you rather build the tallest snowman or decorate the biggest tree?
12. Would you rather ride in Santa’s sleigh or ride the Polar Express?
13. Would you rather meet Rudolph or meet Frosty?
14. Would you rather get unlimited candy canes or unlimited hot chocolate?
15. Would you rather open one big present or five small presents?
16. Would you rather make toys with elves or bake treats in Mrs. Claus’s kitchen?
17. Would you rather have a pet reindeer or a pet snowman?
18. Would you rather help Santa deliver presents or help decorate the North Pole?
19. Would you rather sing carols with elves or dance with snowflakes?
20. Would you rather live in a gingerbread house or live in a toy workshop?

Food-Themed Christmas Would You Rather Questions

For food lovers, picky eaters, and adventurous players.

21. Would you rather eat only Christmas cookies for a day or only Christmas candy?
22. Would you rather drink hot chocolate with marshmallows or hot chocolate with whipped cream?
23. Would you rather eat gingerbread for every meal or candy canes for every snack?
24. Would you rather decorate cookies or decorate cupcakes?
25. Would you rather bake a giant cookie or build a giant gingerbread house?
26. Would you rather try a new holiday recipe or stick to your favorite dish?
27. Would you rather eat fruitcake once a week or drink eggnog every day?
28. Would you rather have peppermint-flavored everything or cinnamon-flavored everything?
29. Would you rather eat Christmas dinner twice or Christmas dessert twice?
30. Would you rather have unlimited cookies or unlimited hot cocoa?

Winter-Themed Would You Rather Questions

Great for players who love snowy adventures.

31. Would you rather have snow every day in December or no snow at all?
32. Would you rather go sledding down a huge hill or ice skating on a frozen lake?
33. Would you rather build 50 snowmen or make 50 snow angels?
34. Would you rather get snowed in with no electricity or no Wi-Fi?
35. Would you rather start a snowball fight or build a snow fort?
36. Would you rather have a magical snowflake collection or a magical ornament collection?
37. Would you rather shovel a driveway or decorate a huge Christmas tree?
38. Would you rather wear warm mittens forever or warm slippers forever?
39. Would you rather live in a winter wonderland or on a sunny Christmas beach?
40. Would you rather spend a day skiing or spend a day drinking hot cocoa by the fireplace?

Movie Christmas Would You Rather Questions

Perfect for movie fans and holiday film lovers.

41. Would you rather spend the day with Buddy the Elf or the Grinch?
42. Would you rather travel on the Polar Express or visit Whoville?
43. Would you rather watch one movie all day or watch ten different movies once?
44. Would you rather decorate with the Home Alone family or the Elf workshop crew?
45. Would you rather live in the North Pole from “Elf” or the town from “The Santa Clause”?
46. Would you rather have Frosty as your best friend or Olaf as your best friend?
47. Would you rather sing like in a Christmas musical or act in a Christmas comedy?
48. Would you rather have a starring role in a holiday movie or direct one?
49. Would you rather watch only classic Christmas movies or only new Christmas movies?
50. Would you rather solve a mystery with the Grinch or go on an adventure with Rudolph?

Holiday Spirit Would You Rather Questions

Great for thoughtful moments and deeper discussions.

51. Would you rather give a special gift or receive a surprise gift?
52. Would you rather decorate your whole house or help decorate a friend’s house?
53. Would you rather volunteer at a holiday event or host a holiday game night?
54. Would you rather donate toys or donate warm clothes?
55. Would you rather wrap gifts for others or help people shop for gifts?
56. Would you rather spend Christmas at home or travel somewhere new?
57. Would you rather send holiday cards or deliver small treats to neighbors?
58. Would you rather keep one special tradition forever or start a brand-new one each year?
59. Would you rather plan the Christmas dinner or plan the Christmas games?
60. Would you rather celebrate Christmas with a big group or with a small cozy gathering?

Bonus Would You Rather Questions

Extra questions for longer games and bigger groups.

61. Would you rather receive a gift made by hand or a store-bought gift you really want?
62. Would you rather spend Christmas morning baking or opening presents?
63. Would you rather time travel to Christmas in the past or Christmas in the future?
64. Would you rather have a tree that changes colors or a tree that changes scents?
65. Would you rather have reindeer ears or an elf hat that lights up?

Conclusion

“Would You Rather?” is a simple and exciting game that always brings laughter and fun to the holiday season. These Christmas questions help start conversations, spark creativity, and make everyone feel included—kids, teens, and adults alike. Whether you’re using them for a classroom activity, a family gathering, a Christmas party, or a cozy evening at home, this list of 60+ questions is perfect for creating warm memories and joyful moments.